Pick a Fight Battles Rankings Characters Tier Lists Blog

© 2026 WhoWouldWinComics.com

Rankings Battles Characters Tier Lists Blog Publishers Stats About

Character data provided by Comic Vine, Superhero API, Wikipedia, and Fandom. All character names and images are property of their respective owners.

Who Would Win: Martian Manhunter vs Stargirl? | Who Would Win Comics

Who Would Win?

Martian Manhunter - character image

Martian Manhunter

J'onn J'onzz

1375pts

168W / 149L

Real Name

J'onn J'onzz

Occupation

Detective, Justice League member

Powers

Shape-Shifting, Telepathy, Superhuman Strength, Flight, Intangibility, Invisibility, Martian Vision, Regeneration

Equipment

Martian technology (rarely used — relies on innate powers)

Teams

Darkstars, Justice League of Aliens, Justice League Of America, Justice League Task Force, Justice League Unlimited, Martians, Outsiders

VS

Stargirl - character image

Stargirl

Courtney Whitmore

1154pts

74W / 153L

Real Name

Courtney Whitmore

Occupation

Student / Adventurer

Powers

Cosmic Staff (Flight), Cosmic Staff (Energy Blasts), Cosmic Converter Belt (Enhanced Strength), Star-Spangled Combat

Equipment

Cosmic Staff, Cosmic Converter Belt

Teams

Justice Society of America

0/280

View full stats comparison →

Related Battles

Stargirl

Stargirl vs Darkseid

8%-92% · 12 votes

Darkseid

Bane

Bane vs Martian Manhunter

27%-73% · 11 votes

Martian Manhunter

Martian Manhunter

Martian Manhunter vs Thragg

56%-44% · 9 votes

Thragg

Dormammu

Dormammu vs Martian Manhunter

63%-37% · 8 votes

Martian Manhunter

Nightcrawler

Nightcrawler vs Martian Manhunter

57%-43% · 7 votes

Martian Manhunter

Martian Manhunter

Martian Manhunter vs Venom

57%-43% · 7 votes

Venom